• ‘Islamic takeover plot’ in Birmingham schools investigated

    As a teacher, I cannot tell you how much this worries me. I will be striking later this month in opposition to this government push on ‘free schools’ an academies which is  thinly veiled attempt to privatise education and politically liberalise it. I could bore you for hours on the ramifications and implications of such a stupid approach to education, not least adding in the utter stupidity of scrapping a national curriculum and assessment framework whilst neglecting to be organised enough to have something in mind and prepared to replace it. Total idiots. And yes, if I meet Education Secretary Michael Gove in a dark alley…

    As an aside, here is what controversial Twitter account Tory Eduction News (for US readers, the Tories are the Conservative party in charge with a coalition becoming more right wing by the month) had to say recently:

    So they are wanting to deregulate education, get rid of Local Authority education teams, and use the Department for Education just as accountants, and get rid of OFSTED who check schools for quality provision, and politicians will have zero control. In other words, schools can do what the fuck they want, but it’s ok because spending will go down… Playing games with education is criminal. Letting religion interfere with education is criminal.

    Which leads on to this article. Without centralised and fair control of our education system, something we are losing, we can have any nutjob ideologist running our schools. As the BBC reports:

    An alleged plot to oust some Birmingham head teachers and make their schools adhere to more Islamic principles is being investigated, it has emerged.

    A letter detailing the plan, known as “Operation Trojan Horse”, claims responsibility for leadership changes at four schools.

    These schools are Adderley Primary, Saltley School, Park View School and Regents Park Community Primary School.

    Saltley’s head teacher resigned last year after a critical Ofsted report.

    Inspectors said there was a “dysfunctional” relationship between head teacher Balwant Bains and governors which was hindering the school.

    The letter, which purports to outline “Operation Trojan Horse”, has subsequently been sent to at least another 12 schools in the city – all believed to be vulnerable to takeover.

    It states that parents could be encouraged to turn against the leadership team if they are told the school is “corrupting their children with sex education, teaching about homosexuals, making their children pray Christian prayers and [carrying out] mixed swimming and sport”.

    Among various claims in the letter is one that the group has “caused a great amount of organised disruption in Birmingham and as a result we have our own academies and are on the way to getting rid of more head teachers and taking over their schools”.

    The head teachers of the schools met Birmingham City Council on Thursday to discuss their concerns.

    The letter, seen by the BBC, was apparently written by someone in Birmingham to a contact in Bradford, and goes on to outline ways and means by which schools can be taken over.School sign composite image

    It says: “We have an obligation to our children to fulfil our roles and ensure these schools are run on Islamic principles.”

    It is understood that would mean a greater emphasis on religious studies, as well as girls and boys being taught separately in some classes.

    The letter implies these methods have already been put into action and urges the recipient to use Ofsted reports to identify schools in predominantly Muslim areas which are struggling.

    It adds: ”Operation ‘Trojan Horse’ has been very carefully thought through and is tried and tested within Birmingham, implementing it in Bradford will not be difficult for you.”

    It says that Salafi parents should be enlisted to help, because they are regarded as a more orthodox branch of Islam and would be more likely to be willing to help.

    It was sent to the city council in 2013 and has led to a number of investigations. Part of the inquiry will focus on whether the plot is genuine or fake.

    A Birmingham City Council spokesperson confirmed the letters had been received and that an investigation was ongoing.

    The Department for Education’s (DfE) Extremist Unit is also involved and the West Midlands Police Counter-Terrorism Unit has also looked into the case after being handed the letter in December 2013.

    Supt Sue Southern, head of the unit, said it was decided the allegations in the letter were “not a matter for the police”.

    The National Association of Head Teachers (NAHT) said it had “received some anonymous letters in February which claimed that an extremist religious group was trying to engineer the sacking of head teachers who did not promote the group’s ideals”.

    It said it was working with the police, the Department for Education and Birmingham City Council to investigate the claim.

    Russell Hobby, NAHT general secretary, said the union took the allegations “extremely seriously”.

    Liam Byrne, Labour MP for Hodge Hill, said he had held urgent talks with Ofsted, City Council officials, the office of Michael Gove and DfE officials.

    “These are deeply disturbing allegations, which is why Ofsted has been called in,” he said.

    “I have demanded that the second we have results from those inspections, both the city council and the Secretary of State take immediate action.”



    Although the authorities have been aware of the alleged plot since November, the details have only become public now thanks to the letter which has been widely leaked.

    We still don’t know whether it’s genuine or a fake, but that’s one of the questions the city council is attempting to answer with its investigation.

    It’s clearly a sensitive subject and there will be great concerns about the effect on what the authorities euphemistically call “community cohesion”.

    Finding anyone who is directly involved and prepared to go on the record has also proved difficult.

    No-one wants to be called an “Islamaphobe” or a racist, nor do they wish to be labelled a right wing conspiracy theorist.

    There’s also a sense of fear among potential whistleblowers that speaking publicly will mean an end to their careers.


    Trojan Horse’s Five Steps:

    • Identify ‘target schools’ based in Muslim areas
    • Select a group of Salafi parents within the school community. The letter says they are “most committed to Islam” and “once charged up they keep going for longer”
    • Install a governor within the school to “drip feed” ideals for a Muslim school
    • Identify “weak and disgruntled staff” and encourage them to complain so an external investigation is launched
    • Instigate an anonymous letter campaign to local MPs, education authorities and others

    Category: EducationFeaturedIslamSecularism


    Article by: Jonathan MS Pearce