{"id":740,"date":"2013-03-26T08:36:33","date_gmt":"2013-03-26T13:36:33","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/smilodonsretreat\/?p=740"},"modified":"2013-03-26T08:36:33","modified_gmt":"2013-03-26T13:36:33","slug":"information-and-intelligent-design-again","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/smilodonsretreat\/2013\/03\/26\/information-and-intelligent-design-again\/","title":{"rendered":"Information and Intelligent Design&#8230; again"},"content":{"rendered":"<p>Apparently, I have to do this again.<\/p>\n<p>It&#8217;s really quite simple.\u00a0 Information, in the technical sense of being calculable, is not meaning.\u00a0 It is trivially easy to calculate the amount of information in something.\u00a0 Computers do it thousands of times a day.\u00a0 They do not calculate the meaning or something.<\/p>\n<p>To a computer (and everyone else).<\/p>\n<p>JEBFGWUBGBWGWHIEGIWHOIGHWEGDSJFGUWOBGG<\/p>\n<p>has the same amount of information as<\/p>\n<p>THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG.<\/p>\n<p>One of the above has meaning for a subset of the humans on the planet and one does not.\u00a0 Meaning is simply not calculable.<\/p>\n<p>Why?\u00a0 Because meaning is dependent on the on the environment.\u00a0 To someone who has no knowledge of the English language, the second sentence above has as much meaning as the first.\u00a0 Zero.\u00a0 To a person knowledgeable about English, the second sentence has more meaning than the first.\u00a0 How much more?\u00a0 It&#8217;s incalculable.<\/p>\n<p>A person can be capable of reading the entire sentence, but not know what a &#8216;fox&#8217; is.\u00a0 That&#8217;s less meaning than it would be to someone that does know what a fox is.\u00a0 What about a blind person reading this by braille, they know that &#8216;brown&#8217; is a color, but have no idea what that really means.<\/p>\n<p>We can play this game in the real world just as easily.<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>ATG GTG GAC CTG ACT CCT G<strong>T<\/strong>G GAG AAG TCT GCC GTT ACT GCC CTG TGG GGC AAG GTG<br \/>\nAAC GTG GAT GAA GGT GGT GTT GAG GCC CTG GGC AGGTTGGTATCAAGGTTACAAGACAGGTTTAAG<br \/>\nGAGACCAATAGAAACTGGGCATGTGGAGACAGAGAAGACTCTTGGGTTTCTGATAGGCACTGACTCTCTCTGCCTATT<br \/>\nGGTCTATTTTCCCACCCTTAG G CTG CTG GTG GTC TAC CCT TGG ACC CAG AGG TTC TTT GAG<br \/>\nTCC TTT GGG GAT CTG TCC ACT CCT GAT GCT GTT ATG GGC AAC CCT AAG GTG AAG GCT<br \/>\nCAT GGC AAG AAA GTG CTC GGT GCC TTT AGT GAT GGC CTG GCT CAC CTG GAC AAC CTC<br \/>\nAAG GGC ACC TTT GCC ACA CTG AGT GAG CTG CAC TGT GAC AAG CTG CAC GTG GAT CCT<br \/>\nGAG AAC TTC AGG GTGAGTCTATGGGACCCTTGATGTTTTCTTTCCCCTTCTTTTCTATGGTTAAGTTCATGTC<br \/>\nATAGGAAGGGGAGAAGTAACAGGGTACAGTTTAGAATGGGAAACAGACGAATGATTGCATCAGTGTGGAAGTCTCA<br \/>\nGGATCGTTTTAGTTTCTTTTATTTGCTGTTCATAACAATTGTTTTCTTTTGTTTAATTCTTGCTTTCTTTTTTTTTCT<br \/>\nTCTCCGCAATTTTTACTATTATACTTAATGCCTTAACATTGTGTATAACAAAAGGAAATATCTCTGAGATACATTAAG<br \/>\nTAACTTAAAAAAAAACTTTACACAGTCTGCCTAGTACATTACTATTTGGAATATATGTGTGCTTATTTGCATATTCAT<br \/>\nAATCTCCCTACTTTATTTTCTTTTATTTTTAATTGATACATAATCATTATACATATTTATGGGTTAAAGTGTAATGTT<br \/>\nTTAATATGTGTACACATATTGACCAAATCAGGGTAATTTTGCATTTGTAATTTTAAAAAATGCTTTCTTCTTTTAATA<br \/>\nTACTTTTTTGTTTATCTTATTTCTAATACTTTCCCTAATCTCTTTCTTTCAGGGCAATAATGATACAATGTATCATGC<br \/>\nCTCTTTGCACCATTCTAAAGAATAACAGTGATAATTTCTGGGTTAAGGCAATAGCAATATTTCTGCATATAAATATTT<br \/>\nCTGCATATAAATTGTAACTGATGTAAGAGGTTTCATATTGCTAATAGCAGCTACAATCCAGCTACCATTCTGCTTTTA<br \/>\nTTTTATGGTTGGGATAAGGCTGGATTATTCTGAGTCCAAGCTAGGCCCTTTTGCTAATCATGTTCATACCTCTTATCT<br \/>\nTCCTCCCACAG CTC CTG GGC AAC GTG CTG GTC TGT GTG CTG GCC CAT CAC TTT GGC AAA<br \/>\nGAA TTC ATC CCA CCA GTG CAG GCT GCC TAT CAG AAA GTG GTG GCT GGT GTG GCT AAT<br \/>\nGCC CTG GCC CAC AAG TAT CAC TAA GCTCGCTTTCTTGCTGTCCAATTTCTATTAAAGGTTCCTTTGTT<br \/>\nCCCTAAGTCCAACTACTAAACTGGGGGATATTATGAAGGGCCTTGAGCATCTGGATTCTGCCTAATAAAAAACATTTA<br \/>\nTTTTCATTGCAATGATGTATTTAAATTATTTCTGAATATTTTACTAAAAAGGGAATGTGGGAGGTCAGTGCATTTAAA<br \/>\nACATAAAGAAATGATGAGCTGTTCAAACCTTGGGAAAATACACTATATCTTAAACTCCATGAAAGAA<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p>and<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>ATG GTG GAC CTG ACT CCT G<strong>A<\/strong>G GAG AAG TCT GCC GTT ACT GCC CTG TGG GGC AAG GTG<br \/>\nAAC GTG GAT GAA GGT GGT GTT GAG GCC CTG GGC AGGTTGGTATCAAGGTTACAAGACAGGTTTAAG<br \/>\nGAGACCAATAGAAACTGGGCATGTGGAGACAGAGAAGACTCTTGGGTTTCTGATAGGCACTGACTCTCTCTGCCTATT<br \/>\nGGTCTATTTTCCCACCCTTAG G CTG CTG GTG GTC TAC CCT TGG ACC CAG AGG TTC TTT GAG<br \/>\nTCC TTT GGG GAT CTG TCC ACT CCT GAT GCT GTT ATG GGC AAC CCT AAG GTG AAG GCT<br \/>\nCAT GGC AAG AAA GTG CTC GGT GCC TTT AGT GAT GGC CTG GCT CAC CTG GAC AAC CTC<br \/>\nAAG GGC ACC TTT GCC ACA CTG AGT GAG CTG CAC TGT GAC AAG CTG CAC GTG GAT CCT<br \/>\nGAG AAC TTC AGG GTGAGTCTATGGGACGCTTGATGTTTTCTTTCCCCTTCTTTTCTATGGTTAAGTTCATGTC<br \/>\nATAGGAAGGGGAGAAGTAACAGGGTACAGTTTAGAATGGGAAACAGACGAATGATTGCATCAGTGTGGAAGTCTCA<br \/>\nGGATCGTTTTAGTTTCTTTTATTTGCTGTTCATAACAATTGTTTTCTTTTGTTTAATTCTTGCTTTCTTTTTTTTTCT<br \/>\nTCTCCGCAATTTTTACTATTATACTTAATGCCTTAACATTGTGTATAACAAAAGGAAATATCTCTGAGATACATTAAG<br \/>\nTAACTTAAAAAAAAACTTTACACAGTCTGCCTAGTACATTACTATTTGGAATATATGTGTGCTTATTTGCATATTCAT<br \/>\nAATCTCCCTACTTTATTTTCTTTTATTTTTAATTGATACATAATCATTATACATATTTATGGGTTAAAGTGTAATGTT<br \/>\nTTAATATGTGTACACATATTGACCAAATCAGGGTAATTTTGCATTTGTAATTTTAAAAAATGCTTTCTTCTTTTAATA<br \/>\nTACTTTTTTGTTTATCTTATTTCTAATACTTTCCCTAATCTCTTTCTTTCAGGGCAATAATGATACAATGTATCATGC<br \/>\nCTCTTTGCACCATTCTAAAGAATAACAGTGATAATTTCTGGGTTAAGGCAATAGCAATATTTCTGCATATAAATATTT<br \/>\nCTGCATATAAATTGTAACTGATGTAAGAGGTTTCATATTGCTAATAGCAGCTACAATCCAGCTACCATTCTGCTTTTA<br \/>\nTTTTATGGTTGGGATAAGGCTGGATTATTCTGAGTCCAAGCTAGGCCCTTTTGCTAATCATGTTCATACCTCTTATCT<br \/>\nTCCTCCCACAG CTC CTG GGC AAC GTG CTG GTC TGT GTG CTG GCC CAT CAC TTT GGC AAA<br \/>\nGAA TTC ATC CCA CCA GTG CAG GCT GCC TAT CAG AAA GTG GTG GCT GGT GTG GCT AAT<br \/>\nGCC CTG GCC CAC AAG TAT CAC TAA GCTCGCTTTCTTGCTGTCCAATTTCTATTAAAGGTTCCTTTGTT<br \/>\nCCCTAAGTCCAACTACTAAACTGGGGGATATTATGAAGGGCCTTGAGCATCTGGATTCTGCCTAATAAAAAACATTTA<br \/>\nTTTTCATTGCAATGATGTATTTAAATTATTTCTGAATATTTTACTAAAAAGGGAATGTGGGAGGTCAGTGCATTTAAA<br \/>\nACATAAAGAAATGATGAGCTGTTCAAACCTTGGGAAAATACACTATATCTTAAACTCCATGAAAGAA<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p>Are both alleles of a specific gene in the human body.\u00a0 Both of these alleles are exactly the same length.\u00a0 The only difference between the two of them is that bold letter.<\/p>\n<p>That&#8217;s called a &#8216;point mutation&#8217; and it&#8217;s just what it says.\u00a0 One point on the gene has changed from one nucleotide to another nucleotide.<\/p>\n<p>Since they are the same length and it takes the same number of bits to code for each letter (two bits in this case), then each allele has exactly the same amount of information.<\/p>\n<p>However, the MEANING of the two is very different.\u00a0 One produces a normal HBB-B protein, while the other produces a mutant form of the HBB-B protein.\u00a0 The mutant form results in red blood cells not being a nice torus shape, but instead a pointy, sickle shape.<\/p>\n<p>Yes, that one change is responsible for sickle cell anemia.<\/p>\n<p>The meaning of one of these alleles is incalculable without considering the environment (and the other allele of the gene in question).\u00a0 In an environment without the malaria causing parasite, the normal allele has a higher fitness.\u00a0 Because it doesn&#8217;t cause sickle cell-shaped red-blood cells, it is more efficient at transporting oxygen.<\/p>\n<p>However, in an environment that does have the malaria causing parasite, the &#8216;normal&#8217; allele is at a disadvantage.\u00a0 This is because the mutant allele creates red-blood cells that cannot be harmed by the malaria parasite (effectively).<\/p>\n<p>However, two alleles for sickle-cell are bad.\u00a0 One allele is sufficient to provide malaria resistance.\u00a0 Two alleles result in the disease &#8216;sickle-cell anemia&#8217; and is worse than getting malaria.<\/p>\n<p>Now, if any ID proponent can write up and explanation, including the calculations and reasons behind the calculations, for how the <strong>meaning<\/strong> of these alleles can be calculated, then I will post it as a special guest post.<\/p>\n<p>If any ID proponent can provide me a link to a page where there are detailed instructions and examples for this process, then I will happily do the work myself.<\/p>\n<p>But until that happens, there is no reason to believe that information = meaning, in a calculable sense.\u00a0 Which makes the ID proposition about said calculations (can&#8217;t create information and the like) meaningless.<\/p>\n<p>So if the ID proponent says that we can&#8217;t &#8216;create&#8217; information, then they are wrong.\u00a0 Because information is calculable.\u00a0 So any mistake that increases the amount of bits required for the gene or whatever increases the information.\u00a0 An insertion mutation, a copying of the gene, a chromosome problem that results in trisomy.\u00a0 All of those increase information.<\/p>\n<p>Do, they increase meaning?\u00a0 Maybe, maybe not, but until they can actually calculate meaning (and they can&#8217;t), then talking about it is a meaningless exercise.<\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>Apparently, I have to do this again. It&#8217;s really quite simple.\u00a0 Information, in the technical sense of being calculable, is&hellip;<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":27,"featured_media":0,"comment_status":"open","ping_status":"open","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"footnotes":""},"categories":[24,28,11],"tags":[939,353,283,354,937],"class_list":["post-740","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","hentry","category-creationism","category-genetics","category-skepticism","tag-creationism","tag-information","tag-intelligent-design","tag-meaning","tag-science"],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/smilodonsretreat\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/740","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/smilodonsretreat\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/smilodonsretreat\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/smilodonsretreat\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/27"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/smilodonsretreat\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=740"}],"version-history":[{"count":0,"href":"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/smilodonsretreat\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/740\/revisions"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/smilodonsretreat\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=740"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/smilodonsretreat\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=740"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/smilodonsretreat\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=740"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}