{"id":1164,"date":"2014-03-19T11:03:48","date_gmt":"2014-03-19T11:03:48","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/?p=1164"},"modified":"2014-05-25T12:58:01","modified_gmt":"2014-05-25T12:58:01","slug":"about-those-mann-replications","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/2014\/03\/19\/about-those-mann-replications\/","title":{"rendered":"Was Mann&#8217;s graph replicated independently?  &#8211; UPDATED and Corrected"},"content":{"rendered":"<p>David Appell has taken umbrage at my comment that I haven&#8217;t seen anything as extreme as the original Mann Hockey stick in the literature, saying that Mann&#8217;s work has been replicated &#8216;by many different groups&#8217;. \u00a0I&#8217;m wondering whether that is true in the same way that Mann <a href=\"http:\/\/www.steynonline.com\/6134\/every-quote-ever-uttered-by-anyone-exonerates\">&#8220;was exonerated by all investigations&#8221;<\/a>. \u00a0Let&#8217;s look.<\/p>\n<p>Here is the original Michael E. Mann Hockey stick:<\/p>\n<p>&nbsp;<\/p>\n<figure id=\"attachment_1165\" aria-describedby=\"caption-attachment-1165\" style=\"width: 300px\" class=\"wp-caption aligncenter\"><a href=\"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/OriginalHockeyStick.jpg\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" class=\"size-medium wp-image-1165\" alt=\"Hockey Stick from the original paper in 1999\" src=\"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/OriginalHockeyStick-300x197.jpg\" width=\"300\" height=\"197\" srcset=\"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/OriginalHockeyStick-300x197.jpg 300w, https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/OriginalHockeyStick.jpg 748w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 300px) 100vw, 300px\" \/><\/a><figcaption id=\"caption-attachment-1165\" class=\"wp-caption-text\">Hockey Stick from the original paper in 1999<\/figcaption><\/figure>\n<p>&nbsp;<\/p>\n<p>A few things to note, because they get very important later on. \u00a0First of all, the scale &#8211; notice that the tip of the hockey stick blade reaches a maximum of about 0.75-0.8C on the temperature anomaly scale. \u00a0Note also the absence of the medieval warm period, little ice age, etc.<\/p>\n<p>I&#8217;m going to repeat myself here, since I don&#8217;t want any semantic wrangling: I have seen a suspicious uptick in the twentieth century but nothing quite on the scale of what Mann shows.<\/p>\n<p><del>Here is the hockey stick from the <a href=\"http:\/\/www.nature.com\/ngeo\/journal\/v6\/n5\/full\/ngeo1797.html\">PAGES2K<\/a> consortium cited by Appel:<\/del><\/p>\n<p>Here are various prior reconstructions that show that even Mann isn&#8217;t peddling his stupid stick anymore, not when other people cna check his work:<\/p>\n<p>&nbsp;<\/p>\n<figure id=\"attachment_1168\" aria-describedby=\"caption-attachment-1168\" style=\"width: 1024px\" class=\"wp-caption aligncenter\"><a href=\"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/pages2k.jpg\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" class=\"size-large wp-image-1168\" alt=\"PAGES2K hockey stick\" src=\"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/pages2k-1024x162.jpg\" width=\"1024\" height=\"162\" srcset=\"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/pages2k-1024x162.jpg 1024w, https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/pages2k-300x47.jpg 300w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 1024px) 100vw, 1024px\" \/><\/a><figcaption id=\"caption-attachment-1168\" class=\"wp-caption-text\"><del>PAGES2K hockey stick\u00a0<\/del> Previous reconstructions<\/figcaption><\/figure>\n<p>A couple of things to note. \u00a0First of all, look at the scale &#8211; the\u00a0<em>maximum value<\/em> for the temperature anomaly is higher than that listed in the original graph. \u00a0Second, notice that the current anomaly is listed as being pretty much that of a 1000 years ago. \u00a0Third, notice the &#8220;Mann EIV&#8221; bit; even Mann isn&#8217;t defending his original hockey stick anymore (more on that later).<\/p>\n<p>Here we have the hockey sticks from<a href=\"http:\/\/www.sciencemag.org\/content\/339\/6124\/1198.abstract\"> Marcott et al<\/a>, also cited by Appel:<\/p>\n<p>&nbsp;<\/p>\n<p>&nbsp;<\/p>\n<figure id=\"attachment_1169\" aria-describedby=\"caption-attachment-1169\" style=\"width: 948px\" class=\"wp-caption aligncenter\"><a href=\"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/F1.large_.jpg\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" class=\"size-full wp-image-1169\" alt=\"F1 from Marcott et al\" src=\"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/F1.large_.jpg\" width=\"948\" height=\"314\" srcset=\"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/F1.large_.jpg 948w, https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/F1.large_-300x99.jpg 300w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 948px) 100vw, 948px\" \/><\/a><figcaption id=\"caption-attachment-1169\" class=\"wp-caption-text\">F1 from Marcott et al<\/figcaption><\/figure>\n<p>&nbsp;<\/p>\n<figure id=\"attachment_1170\" aria-describedby=\"caption-attachment-1170\" style=\"width: 680px\" class=\"wp-caption aligncenter\"><a href=\"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/F2.large_.jpg\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" class=\"size-full wp-image-1170\" alt=\"F2 from Marcott et al\" src=\"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/F2.large_.jpg\" width=\"680\" height=\"649\" srcset=\"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/F2.large_.jpg 680w, https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/F2.large_-300x286.jpg 300w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 680px) 100vw, 680px\" \/><\/a><figcaption id=\"caption-attachment-1170\" class=\"wp-caption-text\">F2 from Marcott et al<\/figcaption><\/figure>\n<p>&nbsp;<\/p>\n<p>Some look like Mann&#8217;s, in terms of the blade, but other don&#8217;t. \u00a0And again, there is the large warming 1000 years ago that Mann&#8217;s original graph doesn&#8217;t have.<\/p>\n<p>Let&#8217;s <a href=\"http:\/\/www.nature.com\/nature\/journal\/v433\/n7026\/full\/nature03265.html\">continue<\/a>:<\/p>\n<figure id=\"attachment_1171\" aria-describedby=\"caption-attachment-1171\" style=\"width: 305px\" class=\"wp-caption aligncenter\"><a href=\"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/Mobergetal.jpg\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" class=\"size-full wp-image-1171\" alt=\"Mobergetal\" src=\"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/Mobergetal.jpg\" width=\"305\" height=\"490\" srcset=\"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/Mobergetal.jpg 305w, https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/Mobergetal-186x300.jpg 186w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 305px) 100vw, 305px\" \/><\/a><figcaption id=\"caption-attachment-1171\" class=\"wp-caption-text\">From Moberg et al<\/figcaption><\/figure>\n<p style=\"text-align: left\">\u00a0Only one of these even gets close to Mann&#8217;s graph and it is the one that does the highly annoying thing of adding on instrumental records directly onto proxy ones (drop it &#8211; given that this is such a controversial method, there should be stone cold proof independent of this one). \u00a0Notice again the restricted range.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: left\">Here&#8217;s another one, from <a href=\"http:\/\/www.sciencemag.org\/content\/295\/5563\/2250.full\">Esper et al<\/a>:<\/p>\n<figure id=\"attachment_1172\" aria-describedby=\"caption-attachment-1172\" style=\"width: 614px\" class=\"wp-caption aligncenter\"><a href=\"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/F3.large_.jpg\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" class=\" wp-image-1172 \" alt=\"Esper et al\" src=\"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/F3.large_-1024x432.jpg\" width=\"614\" height=\"259\" srcset=\"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/F3.large_-1024x432.jpg 1024w, https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/F3.large_-300x126.jpg 300w, https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/F3.large_.jpg 1280w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 614px) 100vw, 614px\" \/><\/a><figcaption id=\"caption-attachment-1172\" class=\"wp-caption-text\">Esper et al<\/figcaption><\/figure>\n<p style=\"text-align: left\">Speaks for itself, I think. \u00a0And the paper specifically stressed the presence of the Medieval Warm Period (Argument from Appel: the MWP was a local phenomena of the Northern Hemisphere. \u00a0My response: Half the planet isn&#8217;t &#8216;local&#8217; no matter how you define it. \u00a0Also, Mann&#8217;s graph only works in the Northern Hemisphere, as has been previously admitted).<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: left\">Here&#8217;s another one from <a href=\"http:\/\/www.sciencemag.org\/content\/292\/5517\/662.full\">Jones et al<\/a>, in collaboration with Briffa:<\/p>\n<figure id=\"attachment_1173\" aria-describedby=\"caption-attachment-1173\" style=\"width: 614px\" class=\"wp-caption aligncenter\"><a href=\"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/Jonesetal.jpg\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" class=\" wp-image-1173 \" alt=\"Jones et al, 2001\" src=\"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/Jonesetal-1024x269.jpg\" width=\"614\" height=\"161\" srcset=\"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/Jonesetal-1024x269.jpg 1024w, https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/Jonesetal-300x78.jpg 300w, https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/Jonesetal.jpg 1280w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 614px) 100vw, 614px\" \/><\/a><figcaption id=\"caption-attachment-1173\" class=\"wp-caption-text\">Jones et al, 2001<\/figcaption><\/figure>\n<p style=\"text-align: left\">\u00a0 Just to really put this one into context, the black line is the instrumental record, and without that you don&#8217;t get a peak different from that of the PAGES2K consortium cited at the top.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align: left\">Three more from Tan et al, published in Geophysical Research Letters:<\/p>\n<figure id=\"attachment_1174\" aria-describedby=\"caption-attachment-1174\" style=\"width: 342px\" class=\"wp-caption aligncenter\"><a href=\"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/grl16986-fig-0002.png\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" class=\" wp-image-1174\" alt=\"grl16986-fig-0002\" src=\"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/grl16986-fig-0002.png\" width=\"342\" height=\"227\" srcset=\"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/grl16986-fig-0002.png 570w, https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/grl16986-fig-0002-300x198.png 300w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 342px) 100vw, 342px\" \/><\/a><figcaption id=\"caption-attachment-1174\" class=\"wp-caption-text\">Tan1<\/figcaption><\/figure>\n<figure id=\"attachment_1175\" aria-describedby=\"caption-attachment-1175\" style=\"width: 342px\" class=\"wp-caption aligncenter\"><a href=\"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/grl16986-fig-0003.png\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" class=\" wp-image-1175 \" alt=\"Tan2\" src=\"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/grl16986-fig-0003.png\" width=\"342\" height=\"221\" srcset=\"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/grl16986-fig-0003.png 570w, https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/grl16986-fig-0003-300x194.png 300w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 342px) 100vw, 342px\" \/><\/a><figcaption id=\"caption-attachment-1175\" class=\"wp-caption-text\">Tan2<\/figcaption><\/figure>\n<p>&nbsp;<\/p>\n<figure id=\"attachment_1176\" aria-describedby=\"caption-attachment-1176\" style=\"width: 342px\" class=\"wp-caption aligncenter\"><a href=\"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/grl16986-fig-0004.png\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" class=\" wp-image-1176 \" alt=\"Tan3\" src=\"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/grl16986-fig-0004.png\" width=\"342\" height=\"187\" srcset=\"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/grl16986-fig-0004.png 570w, https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/grl16986-fig-0004-300x163.png 300w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 342px) 100vw, 342px\" \/><\/a><figcaption id=\"caption-attachment-1176\" class=\"wp-caption-text\">Tan3<\/figcaption><\/figure>\n<p>&nbsp;<\/p>\n<p>The title of that paper, by the by, is a beaut: \u00a0<em>Cyclic rapid warming on centennial-scale revealed by a 2650-year stalagmite record of warm season temperature<\/em>.<\/p>\n<p>&#8230;And so on. \u00a0All taken directly from top notch journals. \u00a0Believe you me, I can keep on doing this, and, indeed, <a href=\"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/2012\/11\/01\/hokey-sticks-for-sale\/\">already have<\/a>. \u00a0Just to quote the National Academy of Sciences, again, in their investigation of Mann:<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>&#8220;The IPCC used it as a visual prominently in the report [&#8230;] I think that sent a very misleading message about how resolved this part of the scientific research was. &#8220;<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p>Did they ever. \u00a0Take another look over the graphs above. \u00a0Then look at Mann&#8217;s published one. \u00a0Then take a look at this:<\/p>\n<figure id=\"attachment_227\" aria-describedby=\"caption-attachment-227\" style=\"width: 427px\" class=\"wp-caption aligncenter\"><a href=\"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2012\/11\/4411032a-i1.01.jpg\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" class=\"size-full wp-image-227\" alt=\"IPCC hockey stick graph\" src=\"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2012\/11\/4411032a-i1.01.jpg\" width=\"427\" height=\"426\" srcset=\"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2012\/11\/4411032a-i1.01.jpg 427w, https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2012\/11\/4411032a-i1.01-150x150.jpg 150w, https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2012\/11\/4411032a-i1.01-300x300.jpg 300w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 427px) 100vw, 427px\" \/><\/a><figcaption id=\"caption-attachment-227\" class=\"wp-caption-text\">IPCC hockey stick graph<\/figcaption><\/figure>\n<p>&nbsp;<\/p>\n<p><em>That<\/em> is the graph Mann was peddling in the IPCC to make his case.<\/p>\n<p>So, in response to Appel&#8217;s comments, this anonymous author can read the literature for himself, and stands by his comments that nothing there is as dramatic as that presented by Mann.<\/p>\n<p><strong>UPDATE AND CORRECTION:<\/strong><\/p>\n<p>Many thanks to David Appell for pointing out that I was wrong in my original attribution up there.\u00a0 That is a horrible oversight of mine, and I am happy to correct here.\u00a0 Here is the full PAGES2K, consisting of a composition of measurements from all seven continents:<\/p>\n<p>&nbsp;<\/p>\n<figure id=\"attachment_1255\" aria-describedby=\"caption-attachment-1255\" style=\"width: 946px\" class=\"wp-caption aligncenter\"><a href=\"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/REalPAGES2K.jpg\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" class=\"size-full wp-image-1255\" alt=\"Real Pages2K Hockey stick\" src=\"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/REalPAGES2K.jpg\" width=\"946\" height=\"333\" srcset=\"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/REalPAGES2K.jpg 946w, https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/REalPAGES2K-300x105.jpg 300w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 946px) 100vw, 946px\" \/><\/a><figcaption id=\"caption-attachment-1255\" class=\"wp-caption-text\">Real Pages2K Hockey stick<\/figcaption><\/figure>\n<p>&nbsp;<\/p>\n<p>The real one is at the bottom.\u00a0 Note the measurements added to the end.\u00a0 And just for the record, here are the individual reconstructions:<\/p>\n<p>&nbsp;<\/p>\n<figure id=\"attachment_1256\" aria-describedby=\"caption-attachment-1256\" style=\"width: 465px\" class=\"wp-caption aligncenter\"><a href=\"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/IndividualPAGES2K.jpg\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" class=\"size-full wp-image-1256\" alt=\"Individual parts of the PAGES2K reconstruction\" src=\"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/IndividualPAGES2K.jpg\" width=\"465\" height=\"812\" srcset=\"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/IndividualPAGES2K.jpg 465w, https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/files\/2014\/03\/IndividualPAGES2K-171x300.jpg 171w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 465px) 100vw, 465px\" \/><\/a><figcaption id=\"caption-attachment-1256\" class=\"wp-caption-text\">Individual parts of the PAGES2K reconstruction<\/figcaption><\/figure>\n<p>&nbsp;<\/p>\n<p>Your mileage may vary of course, but from what I&#8217;m seeing, about three or four of those don&#8217;t look like any sort hockey stick, let alone Mann&#8217;s.<\/p>\n<p>Many thanks to <a href=\"http:\/\/davidappell.blogspot.co.uk\/\">David Appell <\/a>for pointing this out.<\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>David Appell has taken umbrage at my comment that I haven&#8217;t seen anything as extreme as the original Mann Hockey&hellip;<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":22,"featured_media":0,"comment_status":"open","ping_status":"open","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"footnotes":""},"categories":[20],"tags":[],"class_list":["post-1164","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","hentry","category-apgw"],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/1164","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/22"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=1164"}],"version-history":[{"count":1,"href":"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/1164\/revisions"}],"predecessor-version":[{"id":1254,"href":"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/1164\/revisions\/1254"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=1164"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=1164"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/skepticink.com\/prussian\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=1164"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}